**
In a decision that has reignited fierce debate over gender identity and feminism, Glamour UK named a group of transgender influencers—referred to online as “trans dolls”—as Women of the Year. The move drew sharp criticism from Harry Potter author JK Rowling, who quipped sarcastically on social media, “Men are better women.”
Glamour UK’s Controversial Honorees
The Glamour UK Women of the Year Awards, which traditionally celebrate female achievements, included a collective of transgender women known for their glamorous aesthetics and large social media followings. The magazine praised them for “redefining womanhood” and showcasing bravery.
Critics argue that the awards, meant to honor biological women, are being diluted by the inclusion of trans women—many of whom gained fame through beauty rather than activism. Rowling and others question whether this undermines the historical struggles of cisgender women.
JK Rowling’s Viral Clapback
Rowling, a vocal opponent of gender self-ID policies, responded bluntly. Quoting Glamour UK, she tweeted:
“Glamour UK crowns men ‘Women of the Year.’ How progressive. Apparently, men are better women than women. Bravo.”
The tweet went viral, with supporters praising her defense of sex-based rights and critics accusing her of transphobia. Rowling has long argued that conflating gender and sex erases women’s rights in sports, shelters, and female-specific recognitions.
Mixed Reactions from Activists & Celebrities
The decision split public opinion:
– Supporters like trans model Munroe Bergdorf applauded the move, stating: “Trans women have always been women.”
– Critics, including feminist author Naomi Wolf, countered: “Awards for women should center those who face sex-based oppression.”
The divide reflects the broader clash between gender-inclusive feminism and gender-critical feminism—a stance Rowling champions.
The Core Debate: Who Gets to Define Womanhood?
The controversy hinges on a fundamental question: Is womanhood defined by identity or biology?
– Pro-inclusion advocates argue trans women face discrimination and deserve recognition.
– Gender-critical feminists insist biological sex must remain central to women’s rights discussions.
Will the Debate Ever Be Settled?
As institutions like Glamour UK wade into gender politics, tensions escalate. Rowling’s remarks ensure the conversation stays in the spotlight, with no resolution in sight.
Do you think awards like these should include trans women? Share your thoughts in the comments.
— NextMinuteNews Team
**
