Introduction
In the high-stakes world of New York politics, smear campaigns are as common as subway delays. Democratic Socialists of America (DSA) member and New York State Assemblyman Zohran Mamdani found himself at the center of baseless accusations of antisemitism. Conservative opponents and establishment Democrats weaponized his criticism of Israel’s policies, hoping to derail his campaign. Yet Queens voters saw through the deception—and delivered him a decisive victory.
How the Smear Campaign Unfolded
The attacks followed a familiar playbook:
- Critics twisted Mamdani’s support for Palestinian rights into false claims of antisemitism.
- Right-wing media and centrist Democrats amplified the narrative, alleging his stance equated to hatred of Jewish people.
- The timing was strategic—just weeks before the primary election, aiming to sway undecided voters.
But Mamdani, a principled progressive, refused to retreat. He reaffirmed his solidarity with marginalized communities, including Jewish allies critical of Israeli policy. His campaign focused on affordable housing, healthcare, and workers’ rights—issues that resonated in his diverse Queens district.
Voters Rejected the False Narrative
The results spoke for themselves:
- Mamdani won decisively, proving constituents saw the accusations as a cynical political ploy.
- Many voters recognized the smear as a distraction from his tangible policy wins.
In his victory speech, Mamdani declared:
“They thought they could scare people into turning against me. But Queens isn’t afraid of principled politics. We know the difference between justice and hate.”
His win also marked a broader rejection of the tactic equating anti-Zionism with antisemitism—a strategy increasingly used to silence progressives.
A Larger Trend in Progressive Politics
Mamdani’s victory reflects a national pattern:
- Progressive candidates of color, like Rep. Ilhan Omar and former NYC Councilmember Shahana Hanif, have faced similar smears.
- In diverse districts like Queens, voters distinguish between criticism of Israel and hatred of Jewish people.
- Many Jewish voters backed Mamdani, recognizing his stance as rooted in human rights, not bigotry.
What This Means for Future Elections
The failed smear campaign sends a clear message:
- Voters are tired of manipulative fearmongering—they prioritize economic justice, climate action, and racial equity.
- Progressives must stay grounded in grassroots organizing, policy results, and coalition-building to overcome dirty tactics.
Key Takeaway
Mamdani’s re-election isn’t just a win for Queens—it’s a victory for honest politics. As progressives prepare for future battles, his story proves: integrity and solidarity defeat smears.
