Delhi HC Dismisses Christian Michel’s Extradition Treaty Challenge
In a major setback for British middleman Christian Michel, the Delhi High Court dismissed his Public Interest Litigation (PIL) challenging the India-UAE extradition treaty. Michel, a key accused in the ₹3,600 crore AgustaWestland VVIP chopper scam, argued the treaty violated his fundamental rights. The court rejected his plea, reinforcing India’s legal stance on extraditions.
AgustaWestland Scam: Case Background
Christian Michel was extradited from the UAE in December 2018 for his alleged role in the AgustaWestland scandal—a deal involving kickbacks for 12 luxury helicopters during the UPA era. The Enforcement Directorate (ED) and CBI accuse Michel of funneling bribes to Indian officials. His extradition marked a milestone in India’s efforts to repatriate economic offenders.
Michel’s Legal Challenge: Key Arguments
Michel’s PIL claimed the India-UAE extradition treaty was:
– Unconstitutional: Violating Articles 14 (equality) and 21 (liberty).
– Politically Motivated: Alleging fabricated evidence and procedural flaws.
The court, however, ruled the treaty a “sovereign agreement”, dismissing the petition as meritless.
Court’s Verdict & Implications
The bench, led by Chief Justice Satish Chandra Sharma, stated:
“Extradition treaties are bilateral pacts; their validity can’t be questioned via PIL.”
Impact:
– Strengthens India’s extradition framework.
– Limits Michel’s legal options; trial proceeds in Delhi.
Political Reactions
- BJP: Hails the ruling as a win against corruption.
- Opposition: Calls it political vendetta; Congress denies involvement.
What’s Next for Michel?
- Michel remains in Tihar Jail.
- Legal team may appeal to Supreme Court, though success is unlikely.
- Next hearing in AgustaWestland trial scheduled this month.
Conclusion
The verdict underscores India’s commitment to prosecuting high-profile corruption cases. As Michel’s trial advances, the ruling sets a precedent for future extradition challenges.
For real-time updates, follow NextMinuteNews.
