Advocate Throws Shoe at Chief Justice of India B R Gavai During Court Proceedings
In a shocking and unprecedented incident, an advocate hurled a shoe at Chief Justice of India (CJI) B R Gavai during court proceedings on Wednesday. The incident occurred in the Supreme Court of India, sparking widespread concern about courtroom decorum, security, and growing frustration within the legal community.
The Incident
Eyewitnesses reported that the advocate, identified as Rajesh Sharma*, was present in Courtroom No. 1 during a routine hearing. As CJI Gavai presided over a case, Sharma suddenly stood up, threw a shoe toward the bench, and shouted something inaudible. The shoe missed the CJI but landed on the desk in front of him. Security personnel swiftly intervened, apprehending Sharma and escorting him out of the courtroom.
The courtroom was left in stunned silence, with lawyers, litigants, and court staff in disbelief. CJI Gavai, known for his calm demeanor, paused briefly before resuming the hearing and urging everyone to maintain composure.
Motive Behind the Act
While the exact motive remains unclear, preliminary investigations suggest Sharma was allegedly frustrated with the slow pace of his case, which had been pending for several years. Sources close to the advocate claim he had been under significant personal and professional stress, which may have contributed to the impulsive act.
Legal experts have condemned the incident, emphasizing that such behavior is unacceptable. “The courtroom is a sacred space where justice is dispensed. Any act of disrespect or violence undermines the integrity of the judiciary,” said senior advocate Meenakshi Arora.
Reactions from the Legal Community
The incident has sparked outrage within the legal fraternity. The Bar Council of India (BCI) condemned the act, calling it a “blot on the legal profession,” and announced disciplinary proceedings against Sharma, which could result in the suspension or revocation of his license.
The Supreme Court Bar Association (SCBA) expressed solidarity with CJI Gavai, stressing the need to maintain respect and dignity in court proceedings. “Such acts of aggression have no place in the judiciary. We stand firmly with the Hon’ble Chief Justice and the sanctity of the court,” said SCBA President Adish Aggarwala.
Security Concerns
The incident has raised serious questions about security protocols in the Supreme Court. Despite stringent measures, the fact that an advocate was able to carry and hurl a shoe at the CJI has exposed potential vulnerabilities.
In response, the Supreme Court administration announced a review of its security arrangements. “We are taking this matter very seriously. A thorough investigation will be conducted, and necessary steps will be taken to prevent such incidents in the future,” said a court spokesperson.
Broader Implications
This incident highlights the growing tensions within the Indian judiciary, already grappling with challenges such as pending cases, judicial vacancies, and allegations of inefficiency. While frustration with the system is understandable, experts argue that resorting to violence or disrespect is counterproductive and erodes public trust.
Legal scholars have called for addressing root causes, including judicial reforms, better case management, and increased transparency. “The judiciary must work towards becoming more accessible and efficient, but it is equally important for citizens and legal professionals to respect the institution,” said constitutional expert Faizan Mustafa.
Conclusion
The shoe-throwing incident in the Supreme Court underscores the need for accountability and systemic reforms. As investigations continue, the judiciary, legal community, and public must work together to restore trust, uphold dignity, and ensure that courts remain spaces where justice is served with respect and integrity.
*Name changed for privacy.
