Shoe Hurled at Supreme Court Judges: CJI Gavai Responds with Composure
In a shocking incident that has raised concerns about courtroom security, Chief Justice of India (CJI) D.Y. Chandrachud and Justice B.R. Gavai faced a security breach during a hearing in the Supreme Court on 7 October. A litigant hurled a shoe towards the judges, but the incident was met with remarkable calmness, as Justice Gavai stated, “Just ignore it… I am not distracted.”
The Incident Unfolds
The incident occurred in Courtroom No. 1 during a hearing on a land dispute case. Ajay Kumar, a litigant involved in the case, suddenly stood up and threw a shoe towards the judges. The shoe missed its target and landed near the bench. Security personnel swiftly apprehended Kumar and removed him from the courtroom.
Despite the alarming act, CJI Chandrachud and Justice Gavai remained composed. CJI Chandrachud directed security to handle the situation, while Justice Gavai’s calm response, “Just ignore it… I am not distracted,” highlighted the judiciary’s resilience.
Reactions from Legal Experts and Public
The incident has drawn widespread condemnation, with many praising the judges’ dignified response. Senior advocate Kapil Sibal called it an attack on judicial independence, stating, “The sanctity of the court must not be compromised.” Former CJI Ranjan Gogoi emphasized the need for stricter security measures, calling for “zero tolerance” towards such disruptions.
Security Concerns in the Judiciary
The incident has sparked a debate on courtroom security. While the Supreme Court already has measures like metal detectors and frisking in place, experts suggest advanced screening technologies, increased armed guard presence, and psychological evaluations for litigants to prevent similar incidents.
Addressing the Root Cause
This incident reflects growing frustration among litigants due to case backlogs and delays in the legal system. Justice Gavai’s response underscores the judiciary’s commitment to delivering justice despite challenges. However, systemic reforms, including enhanced security and reduced case delays, are essential to restore public confidence.
Conclusion
The shoe-throwing incident is a stark reminder of the vulnerabilities in India’s judicial system. While the judges’ composure is commendable, addressing underlying issues is crucial to safeguarding the judiciary’s integrity. Stay tuned for more updates on this developing story.
