Lawyer Attempts to Hurl Shoe at Supreme Court Judges
In a shocking incident that has sparked nationwide debate, lawyer Manish Kumar attempted to throw a shoe at Chief Justice of India (CJI) DY Chandrachud and Justice BR Gavai during a Supreme Court hearing on Wednesday. The dramatic protest occurred in the middle of a high-profile land dispute case, leaving the courtroom in chaos. Kumar was quickly restrained by security personnel and taken into custody.
Why Did the Lawyer Do It?
In an exclusive interview with Times of India, Kumar revealed his motivations behind the act, stating he has “no regrets.” He claimed his protest was fueled by frustration over what he sees as systemic failures in the judiciary. “It was a moment of desperation, a cry for justice,” he said.
Kumar explained that his clients, farmers from a rural area, have been entangled in a legal battle for over a decade with no resolution. He accused the judiciary of failing marginalized individuals who cannot afford prolonged legal battles. “This is not just about my case. It’s about the thousands denied justice due to a slow, biased, and inaccessible system,” he emphasized.
Reactions from the Legal Fraternity
The incident has ignited a heated debate. While some sympathize with Kumar’s grievances, others condemn his actions as an attack on the judiciary’s sanctity. Legal experts warn that such protests, regardless of intent, undermine the court’s dignity.
Senior advocate Rajeev Dhavan commented, “While frustration is understandable, the courtroom is not the place for such protests. There are better ways to address systemic issues.”
Bar Council of India Condemns the Incident
The Bar Council of India (BCI) has strongly condemned Kumar’s actions, vowing to take strict disciplinary measures. “Such behavior tarnishes the legal profession’s image. We will ensure it doesn’t happen again,” said BCI chairman Manan Kumar Mishra.
Supreme Court Reaffirms Commitment to Justice
The Supreme Court issued a statement urging faith in the judicial process. “The judiciary is democracy’s cornerstone. Incidents like these distract from real issues,” it read.
Calls for Judicial Reform
Kumar’s protest has reignited calls for judicial reforms, including measures to expedite cases, reduce backlogs, and make the system more accessible. While his methods were controversial, they have spotlighted the frustrations faced by many in the legal system.
Kumar Stands by His Actions
Despite the backlash, Kumar remains unapologetic. “I did what I felt was necessary. If this sparks a conversation about justice and reform, it was worth it,” he said.
