Can Zohran Mamdani Lose His US Citizenship?
Recent debates have questioned whether the US government can revoke the citizenship of Zohran Kwame Mamdani, a New York Assemblyman and vocal critic of US foreign policy. Mamdani, a Democratic Socialist representing Queens, has faced backlash for his pro-Palestine activism, prompting speculation about citizenship revocation. But is this legally possible—or just political rhetoric?
When Can the US Government Revoke Citizenship?
US citizenship is highly protected, but revocation is permitted in rare cases under the Immigration and Nationality Act (INA):
1. Fraudulent Naturalization: If citizenship was obtained through lies or concealed facts.
2. Voluntary Renunciation: If a person formally abandons citizenship (e.g., swearing allegiance to another nation).
3. Treason or Rebellion: Requires a criminal conviction for acts like waging war against the US.
Mamdani, a naturalized citizen born in Uganda, hasn’t been accused of fraud. Claims linking his activism to treason lack legal merit.
Political Controversy: Mamdani’s Activism Under Scrutiny
Mamdani’s criticism of US aid to Israel and participation in pro-Palestine protests have drawn accusations of “supporting terrorism” from conservatives. However:
– The First Amendment protects political speech unless it incites imminent violence.
– No evidence suggests Mamdani engaged in criminal activity or material support for terrorist groups.
Historical Cases: Citizenship Revocation in the US
Key Supreme Court rulings limit revocation:
– Afroyim v. Rusk (1967): Citizenship cannot be removed involuntarily.
– Vance v. Terrazas (1980): Intent to abandon citizenship must be proven.
Past revocations involved fraud or wartime treason—neither applies here.
Could It Happen? Legal Realities vs. Political Drama
Absent proof of fraud or treason, revoking Mamdani’s citizenship is legally impossible. The debate reflects broader tensions over free speech and the politicization of citizenship.
Conclusion: Citizenship as a Right, Not a Bargaining Chip
While Mamdani’s views remain divisive, his citizenship is secure. The controversy highlights risks of weaponizing nationality in political disputes—a precedent the courts have repeatedly rejected.
— NextMinuteNews
