The 2024 American League MVP race is one of the most compelling in years, featuring two contrasting candidates: Aaron Judge (New York Yankees) and Cal Raleigh (Seattle Mariners). Judge, a perennial superstar, is rewriting record books, while Raleigh, a breakout catcher, is fueling Seattle’s playoff push. Who holds the edge? Let’s analyze every factor.
The Case for Aaron Judge: Historic Offensive Season
Judge isn’t just leading MVP conversations—he’s chasing history. Key stats as of [current date]:
– MLB-leading home runs (45+), RBI (110+), and OPS (1.100+)
– Top-3 AL WAR (8.5+), blending power (.300+ BA) and elite defense in RF
– Yankees’ lifeline: Carries a lineup riddled with injuries, with 35% of team HRs in critical wins.
His sheer dominance forces pitchers into mistakes, and his defensive range (+5 Defensive Runs Saved) adds hidden value.
The Case for Cal Raleigh: The Ultimate Two-Way Catcher
Raleigh’s 2024 breakout defies expectations:
– 30+ HRs as a catcher (rare power for the position)
– Elite pitch-framing and game-calling (top-3 AL in dWAR)
– Clutch factor: 15 game-winning RBIs for a resurgent Mariners team.
Beyond stats, Raleigh’s leadership transformed Seattle’s pitching staff (3.50 ERA since June). Voters valuing defense and intangibles may lean his way.
Stats Showdown: Traditional vs. Advanced
| Metric | Judge | Raleigh |
|————–|——–|———|
| Home Runs | 48 | 32 |
| WAR | 8.7 | 6.9 |
| dWAR | 0.8 | 2.5 |
| WPA (Win Probability Added) | 5.2 | 4.1 |
Judge’s bat is unmatched, but Raleigh’s defensive edge narrows the gap.
Team Success & Voter Psychology
- Yankees’ playoff spot boosts Judge’s “most valuable” narrative.
- If Seattle overtakes New York, Raleigh’s underdog story gains traction.
- Voter bias: Judge’s fame vs. Raleigh’s “new star” appeal.
Final Prediction: Judge Slightly Ahead
While Raleigh’s all-around impact is extraordinary, Judge’s historic offensive production—and the Yankees’ reliance on him—likely seals the award. But if Seattle surges, expect a tight vote.
Who’s your MVP? Vote in our poll!
