Director Condemns MPA’s NC-17 Rating for Queer Romance
Acclaimed filmmaker Arpita Das has fiercely criticized the Motion Picture Association’s (MPA) decision to give her upcoming queer romantic drama Maya and Samar an NC-17 rating, labeling it “shocking” and “regressive.” The film, which portrays the tender love story of two women in rural India, has won acclaim at international festivals for its poetic depiction of queer joy. Yet Das argues the NC-17 rating—often a box-office hurdle—wrongly frames the film as “explicit” rather than celebrating its emotional depth.
NC-17 Bias: Queer Love vs. Heterosexual Romances
Unlike films with graphic violence or nudity, Maya and Samar features no overtly sexual scenes—its intimacy lies in emotional storytelling and poetic cinematography. Das highlights a glaring double standard:
“Heterosexual romances with far more explicit content get R ratings, but a quiet love story between women is deemed ‘adults only.’ This isn’t about content—it’s about bias.”
Critics and LGBTQ+ advocates agree, citing past films like Blue Is the Warmest Color that faced similar scrutiny. Film scholar Dr. Rahul Kapoor notes, “The NC-17 rating has long been used to marginalize queer narratives under the guise of ‘protecting’ audiences.”
A Celebration of Queer Joy and Resilience
Set in Kerala’s lush landscapes, Maya and Samar follows schoolteacher Maya (Trisha Nair) and artist Samar as they defy prejudice to build a life together. Das calls it a “love letter to queer resilience,” blending magic realism with raw authenticity.
Lead actress Nair adds:
“The real ‘shock’ is that in 2024, love between women is still controversial. The NC-17 rating tells queer audiences their stories are ‘too much’—but love is universal.”
Fighting for Fair Representation
Das is appealing the MPA’s decision, but the issue extends beyond ratings. “This is about whose stories are seen as ‘acceptable,’” she says. “Queer lives deserve the same nuance and respect.”
With its upcoming premiere at the Mumbai International Film Festival, Maya and Samar has ignited a critical conversation: queer stories belong on screen—unfiltered and unapologetic.
—Reporting by NextMinuteNews
Do you think the NC-17 rating unfairly targets queer films? Join the discussion below.
