Wadhera-Dhir Relay Catch: The IPL 2024 Controversy
The Indian Premier League (IPL) 2024 has delivered another unforgettable moment—the Wadhera-Dhir relay catch during the Punjab Kings (PBKS) vs. Mumbai Indians (MI) match. Fans and experts are split: Was it a fair dismissal, or did the umpires get it wrong?
What Happened? The Key Moment
During the high-stakes clash at Wankhede Stadium, MI’s Nehal Wadhera smashed a shot towards deep mid-wicket. PBKS fielders Harpreet Brar and Ashutosh Sharma gave chase, but it was substitute fielder Rishi Dhir who became the center of attention.
Here’s how it unfolded:
1. Brar caught the ball near the boundary but risked stepping over.
2. He quickly relayed it to Dhir, who completed the catch just inside the rope.
3. The third umpire reviewed multiple angles and ruled it OUT, sparking instant debate.
Why Is This Catch Controversial?
The decision hinged on three critical factors:
1. Did Brar Have Full Control Before the Toss?
- Critics argue Brar didn’t secure the ball cleanly before the relay.
- Supporters claim the transfer was clean and within the rules.
2. Was Dhir Inside the Boundary When He Caught It?
- Replays showed Dhir’s feet were millimeters from the rope, but no contact was confirmed.
3. Should the Benefit of Doubt Go to the Batter?
- Some fans believe close calls should favor the batter, while others say technology must decide.
Expert Opinions: What Do the Rules Say?
Under ICC Law 19.4, a relay catch is valid only if:
✅ The first fielder has complete control before releasing.
✅ The second fielder is fully inside the boundary when catching.
Cricket Analysts Weigh In:
– Harbhajan Singh: “It was 50-50. The soft signal mattered—unless there was conclusive evidence to overturn.”
– Ravi Shastri: “Brar’s flick looked clean, but these decisions are razor-thin.”
Fan Reactions: Social Media Divided
Twitter and Instagram exploded with opinions:
– “Robbed! That was a six!” – MI fans
– “Pure brilliance! OUT, no question.” – PBKS supporters
– “Third umpire needs a better angle!” – Neutral viewers
Did the Decision Change the Match?
Wadhera’s dismissal at 28(15) shifted momentum. PBKS won by 5 runs, proving how crucial this call was.
Final Verdict: Out or Not Out?
While the umpire’s decision stands, the debate rages on. With the T20 World Cup 2024 nearing, expect stricter scrutiny on such catches.
What’s Your Take?
📢 Vote in our poll on NextMinuteNews!
